Alternative Scene #6

Dr. SchilhabelJuly 21, 2025July 21, 202535 Comments

Alternative Scene #6: Petrit Vassay Hit-and-run

A theory that has been discussed in online forums suggests that Maura Murray may have been involved in a hit-and-run accident with Petrit Vassay, potentially causing him harm. According to this speculative theory, Maura accidentally struck Petrit, and, in an effort to avoid the consequences, she and her father, Fred, may have staged her disappearance.

The theory proposes that Fred initially made ATM withdrawals to replace the car, but once he saw the extent of the damage, he and Maura decided to cover up the incident. The idea is that they would intentionally damage the car further to hide the evidence of the collision with Petrit. This would explain why the car was found abandoned and why Fred was involved in the financial transactions leading up to Maura’s disappearance.

However, it’s important to note that there is no verified evidence supporting this theory. While the ATM withdrawals and the car’s condition might raise questions, they do not provide concrete proof that a hit-and-run with Petrit was involved or that Fred and Maura deliberately staged the accident. The theory remains purely speculative and lacks substantiation from reliable sources.

Questions for Readers and Investigators

If you’re using the Alternative Scene Tool, consider applying these prompts:

Alternative Scene Tool: Does the theory of a hit-and-run involving Petrit Vassay and the subsequent cover-up align with the known facts? Use the tool to critically assess whether this theory fits with the available evidence.
Timeline Builder Worksheet: How do Fred’s ATM withdrawals fit within the timeline of events? Does it make sense that they were initially intended to replace the car, or does this suggest something more complicated?
Occam’s Razor Tool: Does this theory of a hit-and-run, cover-up, and staged disappearance offer the simplest explanation, or does it complicate the case with additional assumptions?
Cognitive Bias Checklist: Are we being influenced by the dramatic nature of this theory, or are we objectively analyzing the facts of the case based on verified information?

Disclaimer: The Petrit Vassay Hit-and-run theory is purely speculative and lacks verified evidence. While this theory is discussed in some online forums, it is important to approach it with caution. There is no direct evidence linking Maura to a hit-and-run with Petrit, or suggesting that Fred and Maura staged the disappearance. As with all theories, we must focus on verified facts and avoid jumping to conclusions based on circumstantial evidence. If you have read the book and filled out the Alternative Scene Tool, we invite you to submit your completed analysis for further discussion.